Meaning of variable %amount%

Jump to: navigation, search

What is the meaning of the variable %amount%? Is it a number only or a number + a unit, e.g. a currency or a weight unit?

Example: {{plural:%amount%|one=Meat|other=Meat|default=Meat}}

Meat is not countable. It is a collective noun. For me the plural statement does not make sense here. Plural makes sense only if the word is not Meat but Piece of meat.

Example: {{plural:%amount%|one=Piece of meat|other=Pieces of meat|default=Piece of meat}}

But the original string has the collective noun only. With a variable %amount% I would expect a value of type number + unit, e.g.

%amount% {{plural:%amount%|one=Meat|other=Meat|default=Meat}}

Example: 5 kg (as value of %amount%) Meat (as value for the other rule).

But in Upper Sorbian in latter case the collective noun stands in genitive singular for all rules (partitive genitve).

%amount% {{plural:%amount%|one=mjasa|two=mjasa|few=mjasa|other=mjasa|default=Mjaso}}

Example: 5 kg mjasa

Otherwise I had to translate English Meat as časć mjasa (one=) resp. časćow mjasa (other=) corresponding to English Piece of meat:

%amount% {{plural:%amount%|one=časć mjasa|two=časćej mjasa|few=časće mjasa|other=časćow mjasa|default=časće mjasa}}

But this makes sense only if the variable %amount% represents a number only, without a unit.

Example: 10 časćow mjasa

Michawiki (talk)18:26, 30 December 2011

FreeCol uses uncountable nouns as countable. It does not have any units, it's just 5 coats, 12 silver, 34 food....

Nike (talk)10:25, 31 December 2011

Thank you, Nike. But that looks very strange for me. % coats is countable, that's OK. But 12 silver, 34 food... are in my opinion strange, even for English. Or do I think too German? What do you think as Finn abou that?

Michawiki (talk)11:51, 31 December 2011

It could be better. In some translations I've made them as "X units of something" to avoid the awkwardness.

Nike (talk)13:48, 31 December 2011
 
 
 
Personal tools

Variants
Actions
Translators
Navigation
Toolbox
Google AdSense